Could Sigmar have been one of the Missing Primarchs?

You know how there are 2 Primarchs, along with their chapters who have been deleted from imperial records?
Also, you know how occasionally, GW likes to link up their two flagship products through the fluff, like in the supposed upcoming Fantasy campaign involving Space Marines coming through the gate at the pole?

Well it has been insinuated that Sigmar may be one of the missing Primarchs. Due to warp storms surrounding the Warhammer World, the Emperor was never able to link up with him.

Kinda makes sense. A uber human warrior who's coming was heralded by a twin tailed comet. He was a man among children in battle, taking on entire ork hordes by himself ? Leaves mysteriously without having been killed and is destined to one day return?

Sounds very Primarchy to me.

that would be kinda stupid. the two worlds have nothing to do with eachother.

Rokassan wrote:that would be kinda stupid. the two worlds have nothing to do with eachother.

You are wrong here Bill, the wfb and wh40 have lots in common, if you read the history of warhammer, you'll see that the Old ones created the Orcs to help them fight the Necrons and the C'tan, they couldve used the planet to breed the orcs and train them. Also the Lizardmen Slann couldve easely been the ones in charge of minding the planet and making sure the speriments there were going fine. The massive warp storms that struck the galazy and isolated so many of the planets and primarchs couldve kept the planet isolated, and the remember that the chaos gods scattered the primarchs all over the place, one couldve easely been brought in through the warp portal in the poles.

The gods are the same and many ideas have been shared so this is a very feasible concept.

I know the basic concept is the same guys, Im not stupid. One is based in medevil times and one is based in the future though. If they are interchangeable then Im bringing deathguard to the next fantasy campaign.

Rokassan wrote:I know the basic concept is the same guys, Im not stupid. One is based in medevil times and one is based in the future though. If they are interchangeable then Im bringing deathguard to the next fantasy campaign.

Story lines are partially interchangeable, if you really stretch a few things and pretend that the WHFB world is but one lost world in the entire universe that also encompasses the 40K stuff. Some of the books have hinted at links...

Game play is not the same, of course...deathguard in Fantasy...any 40K army in Fantasy is just sickness...a Defiler in a Fantasy game would be beyond ridiculous!!! You're an evil man for even thinking of it...

In the rumored campaign, Space Marines in the Fantasy world will have a Strength 6 toughness 6 with 6 wounds. WS and BS 7. Also a 1+ rerollable armour save. and a devastating ballistic attack.

Ovich wrote:In the rumored campaign, Space Marines in the Fantasy world will have a Strength 6 toughness 6 with 6 wounds. WS and BS 7. Also a 1+ rerollable armour save. and a devastating ballistic attack.

Count me out of that campaign, please...that's just stupid.

Oh come on.. I'm sure parts of it will be pretty cool.

5 Space marines vs. an entire High elf army. hahahahaha.

The space marines will be like... " Sargent, these "elves" seem to be a bit more fragile than the Eldar, I flicked one with my finger and he just exploded"

It would be stupid.

Look, in light of GW's propensity for for screwing up good ideas... maybe they'll be consistent here.

They'll take a bad idea, and make it fun !

Ovich wrote:Look, in light of GW's propensity for for screwing up good ideas... maybe they'll be consistent here.

They'll take a bad idea, and make it fun !

Ahhhh...the eternal optimist...No...these are like the "movie Marines" they had in a White Dwarf about 2 years ago. If memory serves, which at my age is questionable, one of the caveats to playing with that army (against 40K armies), was that you should be beaten for considering using the list, but that it would be "more like the fluff of marines." So, what'da'dey'do...they bring them into Fantasy! Will just be stupid...look serg...I accidently pulled the trigger on my bolter and half his army vanished...

Space Marine Sarge " Brother Lucios, stop standing there in the open and laughing evrytime one of those giant spears bounces from your chest and come here"
Brother Lucios " YES SARGE ! how can be of service?"
Space marine Sarge " brother, ready your missile launcher and take down that annoying giant lizard flying over the squad, the men are getting tired of the guy riding it wavign his hands in the air and all the colorful rays falling down on them"
Brother Lucios, "Yes sir, will do ! may i request the assistance of Brother Malcor?"
Space marine sarge " where is Brother Malcor ?"
Brother Lucios " Oh, last time i saw him he was sorrounded by a bunch of eldar looking guys with big swords"
Space marine sarge " Emperor ! does he needs assistance?"
Brother Lucios " dont worry about it sir, he says they danced arround him and tried poking him with the swords, so he just dropped a frag grenade at his feet and they just went Poof"

hahahahaah that' great !

The fact that the era for fantasy is medieval doesn't matter. There are plenty of worlds stuck in ancient civilizations. Khan conquered a horse planet. Leman Russ conquered a drunkard planet full of viking-esque morons.

I believe that Sigmar is a Primarch. There are many clues to back this up as Stephan has already stated. On the whole marines vs fantasy thing I'd love to do it! Hordes of brown fur against a squad of marines! I'm sure enough warpstone bullets will eventually make a dent in power armor

eh, the Sigmar primarch thing would make sense but who knows for sure.

As for marines in Fantasy, that is really just dumb in my opinion. Reasons stated above pretty much sum it up.